• 实时天气:多伦多 28°
    温度感觉: 27°
  • 实时天气:温哥华 21°
    温度感觉: 23°
  • 实时天气:卡加利 28°
    温度感觉: 26°
  • 实时天气:蒙特利尔 24°
    温度感觉: 28°
  • 实时天气:温尼伯 24°
    温度感觉: 24°
楼主: overcast
打印 上一主题 下一主题

根据中国国籍法:张虹女儿是中国公民(第4集)

106#
发表于 2007-4-21 00:06:55 | 只看该作者
大家都别吵了!
中国总领馆官员没有错,他说的是事实。但是大家都知道,在中国,政策执行的误差太大。
张虹的言论显然逻辑不强,难怪十年了还没有成功的申请难民。
107#
发表于 2007-4-21 08:21:29 | 只看该作者

在国内是算户籍不是算国籍的

说点实际的,

大人出国十年(不管合法非法)文件规定超过1年就丧失户籍了。(具体如何执行全看关系)
小孩已经申领加国护照,所以肯定丧失中国国籍了。

这样一大一小,一个没有户籍,一个没有国籍,请问这位领事官员如何安置呢?

不要说中国公民有任意迁徙的权利,如果你试着给这对母女办一下北京西城区的户口,就明白了。
108#
发表于 2007-4-21 08:22:08 | 只看该作者
最初由[xpxpxpx p]发布
按照上面的说法,张的女儿完全可以持加国护照回国,然后再到当地的派出所上户口。

在这一点上,使馆的人说的很对。

关键就在于:

我国实行的是户籍管理与出入境管理相分离的制度 [/FONT]  


I don't have no time or energy to search info to share but here is my work experience:

Children born in a foreign country to both parents who are Chinese citizenships can apply for a Travel Permit from the local Chinese consulate office to return to China and enjoy benefits like the local kids.  These children can have in their possession their foreign passports but their management will follow exactly the same like other Chinese children.

The official from the Chinese consulate was quite honest, except that I am not sure about his statement of one child policy. There is penalty for sure, but one child policy does not apply to children born overseas.  Also, Sherry is the only child, so there will be no penalty.

I have seen children like Sherry living on a Travel Permit in China for a few years without difficulties.

One problem though. These children may have difficulties proving who they are when returning back to North America. They were babies when they left. They were toddlers when they returned.  Some of them had to do DNA tests to prove who they are.

In my opinion:

1. If Hong Zhang is allowed to stay, there is fine.  After all, she has stayed in this country for 10 years.  Based on the principle of continuity, she has a chance.

2. I don't like the Chinese government, though I have to admit they have made tremendous improvement in the past 10 years.  If Hong Zhang and Sherry leave for China, Sherry will have a life like most Chinese children.  Whether Hong Zhang can find a job in China to support her child is beyond you and me.
109#
发表于 2007-4-21 09:45:26 | 只看该作者
看来张的女儿可以取得中国的国籍应该是没有疑问的了。
110#
发表于 2007-4-21 10:16:17 | 只看该作者
首先, 这个小孩是不是她的,也值得怀疑;其次,即使这孩子是她的,回中国没有任何“低等,下等,歧视”之说。不过,在那都得活出个人样,不能出卖灵魂。这是最起码的为人之道。
111#
发表于 2007-4-21 10:50:40 | 只看该作者
最初由[xpxpxpx p]发布


我无意和您争论,但是这是业内人士写的专业文章无疑,您要是反驳就请从专业角度分析好吗?
嘿嘿,这不难为人吗?还是让她信口开河想说啥说啥吧!
有句中国俗话:哪壶不开提哪壶。
您也真是的。
112#
发表于 2007-4-21 14:38:34 | 只看该作者

我来总结两句:

依法遣返
依情留下
留与不留
看其造化
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 免费注册

本版积分规则

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表