我写的一封给一个大律师的公开信（英文）

唐炜臻

我进监狱几个月以后写的一封给一个律师的公开信（英文），这个律师去年死了。

Weizhen Tang

Collins Bay Institution

P.O.Box 5117, Kingston, Ontario

K7L 0A8

2013-07-27

Mr. Edward Greenspan,  Brian Greenspan

144 King Street East

Toronto, Ontario

M5C 1G8

Open letter to late Mr. Edward L. Greenspan and Mr. Brian H. Greenspan, the pre-eminentcriminal and appeal lawyers of Canadafor media release

Dear Mr. Edward L. Greenspan and Mr. BrianH. Greenspan,

My name is Weizhen Tang, I am a privatehedge fund manager who managed money for accredited investors and millionaire investorsonly. I was exempt to register with a securities regulator, OSC. Some peoplecalled me “The Chinese Warren Buffet”, and invested millions of dollars oftheir money with me. I raised 52 million dollars to Canada in three years and total of60 million. I ‘m a public figure and everybody is watching me and monitoringme, it is impossible for me to defraud anyone in past, now and in the future.

My business was investigated by OSC as earlyas 2005 and registered both with OSC and Texastrade commission of USAin 2008.  I was running a legitimatebusiness, but forced hard landing in 2009 by the authorities.  Any people who work for the government are calledauthorities in Canada.  

Ifind it peculiar that although I raised money by my good name, good image, goodcharacter, good earning power, my honesty and trading skills, my promise and myreputation so that the country, the economy, the community and my investors,all benefited greatly from these efforts yet the OSC and the crown stillcharged me with fraud and convicted me of the charge.

The authorities of OSC, the police and thecrown along with the court accused me of committing the offence of fraud. Theysaid I billed myself “the Chinese Warren Buffet” and were self admittedlyamused by the case. They all agreed on the absence of money, greed and personalgain and conceded that I had nothing but ambition to become the major player inthe market. I must be the only one who would, did and will take loss forinvestors and really put investors’ interest first in Canada and theWestern Countries where all the regulators force investors to take loss ontheir own. My desire was to make money for my investors, to set higher standardsas an example for the securities industry and benefit all investors by seekingand bringing justice to the people.

I was wrongfully convicted on Oct. 30, 2012 andsentenced by the honourable Justice Alfred O’Mara on Feb.1 2013. It is my wishfor immediate appeal of the sentence and conviction including the forfeiture of2.84 million dollars by way of fine. Subsequently, they deprived my right toappeal and denied appeal bail simply because I did not have properrepresentation and they thought my reversing the conviction improbable. Itseems more likely that the crown and the court are fearful that if out on bailI would eventually secure representation and successfully appeal my conviction.

Mr. Greenspan, I heard everybody talk aboutyou and your names and the appeal judges said you had hard fought and left nostone unturned in challenging the crown case for Mr. Drabinsky and Mr. Gottliebin the case of R. v. Drabinsky. You also appealed the cases for them. The crownin my case R. v. Tang used his case as case law, gave me a crown’s book ofauthorities; I did not read it before because I do not understand the law andthe case law as my trial judge said.

Since I have been put into custody at JAU, Joyceville,Kingston and Ihave had plenty of time to read and study. I asked my wife to send me law books and court documents andtranscripts, I read everyday and always think about my case. I read two casesin the book you were working on such as R. v. Drabinsky and R. v. Gaudet, Ifound out they are very interesting and valuable to me and that you are thebest among all other cases, the book of authorities has 15 cases and I read allof them and had a chance to review them and the justice system and find whattheir problems are so I can have a realistic plan how to win my case and know whattakes to win. No doubt, I need the best lawyers, the lawyers like you andrenounced forensic accountant and other industry expert like me, mostimportantly is the money.

After read the case law, I found out that you are indeed both among Canada’s pre-eminent criminal counsel and turned every stoneto challenge the crown, but you did not win any of the big cases like that, no lawyerscould win any cases like that in Canada since there is no fair trial likeGeorge Zimmerman trial in US and no justice in Canada.  Even though you are right and touched everypoint and correctly pointed out that the trial judge did not understand and didnot want to understand, they do not have to and always has apprehension of bias.  

You must remember what the trial judge, who sat in the R. v. Gaudet case and she was honest and tell the truth, said: “It is not possible, nor is it necessary for me to arrive at a full and completeunderstanding of the actions of the three accused which let them to commit thesubject crime. For example, I cannot fully understand why the accused chose todefraud a company in which they were the substantial shareholders and,ultimately victims too, of their own fraud. This is the central theme in theposition of the defence.

Nor do I totally understand how the accused could have believed that they would be able to successfully avoid detectionafter leaving such a paper trail recording their crimes. However, interestingand important those and other questions may be, they need not be resolved. Myfunction is only to determine whether the crown, on all of the evidence, has proven guilt on each count beyond a reasonable doubt, in my view, the crown has successfully met that onus”.

I understand exactly what she was saying and what their problems are and what are the solutions. It seems to me that she was really handicapped by the court of competent, they need help, financial and securities analyst, powerful expert witness before and during the trial to help them understand and they do not know what they were doing, they do not know the risks and responsibility with financial cases except conviction.

All they have is power and all they want is conviction, it is terrible. As I see that you, lawyers can not convince each other because all you are the same and you are all friends.What you need is an external powerful, high profile expert witness and negotiator, mediator, a great strategist like me. We could be an excellent teamor dream team, together we could have enough power and wisdom to win cases likethese and everybody be happy, including the crown.

I think you could only win both of these cases if you could introduce securities industry experts like me who has the knowledge and expertise like you who have on law and court. I know everythingin the securities industry like what you do in criminal law and defence. I understand both of your cases very well in terms of the business, securities and finance and how to analysis and view economically, how to value the case and how to structure a fair solution or find resolution for a case like that and forcethem to be fair and truthful and to make the case work for everybody, not justfor themselves. OSC, the Crown are making harmless, dead mouse case big to fool the public and killing sound business and harm investors and destroy the most needed talent people for thecountry.   

OSC, the Toronto police, legal Aid Ontario, the Crown and I all knew that I could not win my case without a best defence lawyer; I was forced to be self-representedsince they stopped me to access money and to afford a lawyer. Lawyers need money and people to listen, but they do not listen. I could not find a real lawyer who can do better than me including you in the past because all lawyers are dump-truckers who do not have a good strategy and spirit of fighting for their clients,but dump clients to Crown for friendship and favours and old-boy networking.  

I know I could win my case completely if Ihave money and have a defence team like George Zimmerman trial in Florida, USA and my case could be more powerful and usefully like Trayvon Martin, not onlycivil right, charter of rights, but also revolutionize the financial andjustice systems, Trayvon Martin, an innocent black kid, got killed or murdered.I am an innocent financial leader who got slandered. We need each other to win somethingbig and change the system, and we can use my case to build a better justicesystem in Canada.My case clearly demonstrated not only unfair, but also a court of competentjurisdiction at issue.

A fair trial need not only big counsels likeyou and a forensic accountant of defence, but also needs industry veterans likeme, experts with expert opinions and a strategist. I am one of the best in thesecurities industry in the World, I’m a creative financial entrepreneur whoknow how to weigh and value, to solve the financial problems, how to structurea solution and figure out a settlement or fair deal for cases in the securitiesindustry and make case for everybody, win-win situation, otherwise, people donot know and understand the securities industry, only the law is far thanenough, there is no understanding, baseline, no industry standard and common sense,do not know what is the common practice, there is no way to valuate, to analysisand compare in order to make right judgement in court; the only way to settlethe cases is by the opinions of the judge, dictatorship, no sound and objectivejudgement in our court,  that is veryscary and harmful to the public and the economy.

I found out that one of the biggest problemsand fatal problems in securities investigation and prosecution are prosecutor’swrong assumptions and conviction motivation and ignorance, all the prosecutorsassume investors are stupid, greed and victim; they ignore and underestimatethe financial market and the market force, only show their power, destruction, butthey are not smarter than investors and can not protect them; They usually donot consider investors’ real interest, knowledge and their judgement and power.They make and use investors as victims, never use them and their wisdom tosolve the problems, no democracy in prosecution.  

In R. v. Drabinsky case of 2011, the appeal court for Ontario judges (p.166) says: “we would, however, make two observations, first, the investigation and prosecution of crimes like these is difficult and expensive.It places significant stress on the limited resources available to the police and prosecution. An early guilty pleas coupled with full cooperation with thepolice and regulators  and bona fide efforts to compensate those harmed by the frauds has considerable value to theadministration of the justice”  whichmean they do not understand securities frauds and cases, it is difficult andexpensive for them, but not for the regulators and prosecutors in US.

唐炜臻

I raised 17 Million dollars from Texas, US to my business and my operation, most of the money came to Canada, was also investigated by SEC because of OSC, the investigation and prosecution was very easy and cost effective for them, it only took a few weeks or months, not years like OSC and the crown, nobody in my company was charged criminally in US and nor asked for any guilty plea.  Why I should plea guilty if I did nothing wrong.  Why can the Crown stop and drop the case? Only true fraudsters like to plea guilty and plea early, they do not want trial and appeal.

The observations of the judges in appeal court also said (R. v. Drabinsky, para. 167) “The second, individuals who perpetrate frauds like these they are usually seen in the community as solid responsible and law-abiding citizens” , they profile business people as criminal and business as fraud. The second observation mean all those seen in the community as solid responsible and law-abiding citizens are fraudsters and criminal. Especially, the law enforcement personals are really seen lawful; they are seen solid responsible in the society too, right?

Following the appeal judges’ observations, I ‘d like to make one of my own based on my judicial experience and observation that the fraud investigators and the prosecutors, the Crown  do not understand financial and securities issues and the industry, as you correctly pointed out in your submission to the appeal court that  the trial judge took an “overly simplistic and entirely inappropriate approach “, most of the financial prosecutors in Canada are incompetent, dishonest, play dirty and unfair, dishonourable  and disgraceful and disgusting in my view and they cheat tax payer and harm investors and the public.

The Crown and the sentence judge in my case used everything in R.v. Drabinsky case against me, which is wrong, I am not Drabinsky. When I talked about my risk and loss, they also said “often, they suffer personal and financial ruin as a result of the exposure of the fraud”. They do not know that not all those suffer personal and financial ruin as a result of the exposure of the fraud. My investors and I suffered personal and financial ruin was as a result of defamation of the authorities and waves of mass media defamation, the massive destruction of OSC, and especially later of the police and the crown, not as a result of any exposure of any fraud since I did not commit any. I could have explosive growth in business as evidenced if OSC and the police did not get involved and forced me to stop.

It is very frustrated for me since the beginning of the investigation, the crown and trial judge simply did not understand me and did not have the competent to handle the cases like mine. They assumed that I committed a crime and acted on that wrong assumption. As you said they “took an overly simplistic, inappropriate approach” which caused a great deal of damages and harms to me and to my investors. I tried very hard to educate them, to communicate with them and to convince and stop them before the court in order to save all the troubles and resources, they did not want to talk, discover, discuss and negotiate, bargain, they just do not listen. They did not want to listen because I am not Warren buffet who is powerful and every body listen to, but I am the accused and convicted, they just charged ahead railroading me since I did not have a big lawyer like you and no other financial expert and accountant on my behalf.

I told them in advance and warning them many times that they made too many mistakes and troubles, do not do that, but the authorities did not listen, the crown and the court committed massive violations of my charter of rights and legal rights and the rights to have proper representations to me and no fair trial and equality, I have all the court documents to be used and will have all the transcripts to show you and could take serious charter of rights and freedoms enforcement application against them and you make lot of money if you are interested and know how and capable.  As the best lawyers you must have vision like these, see the big opportunity like this and take action decisively and bold, be interested in your bigger  name and reputation and take the business opportunity and go beyond to the next level.

I need a real lawyer and the lawyer know constitution law to win and win it big. I appeal for due process of law: The Canadian Bill of Rights provides that the individual has a right not to be deprived of life, liberty, security of person, or enjoyment of property, except by due process of law. 28. Edw. III, c 3 (1354) made it clear that no person should be harmed in any way “except” by due process of law.  There are massive of violations of my charter rights and freedoms in my case before they prove my guilty in court. Do you know how and could help your client enforcement of guaranteed rights and freedoms:  24. (1) Anyone whose rights or freedoms, as guaranteed by this Charter, have been infringed or denied may apply to a court of competent jurisdiction to obtain such remedy as the court considers appropriate and just in the circumstances. Exclusion of evidence bringing administration of justice into disrepute

(2) Where, in proceedings under subsection (1), a court concludes that evidence was obtained in a manner that infringed or denied any rights or freedoms guaranteed by this Charter, the evidence shall be excluded if it is established that, having regard to all the circumstances, the admission of it in the proceedings would bring the administration of justice into disrepute.

My case is one of the best and most valuable cases in Canada and in the world for a lawyer to prove himself and make new case law and to make money, a big fortune and history, not only because  I am convinced  that I am the “Chinese Warren Buffet” and I am a money man, a number of authorities who use public resources are very interested in my case, as is the media, but also I am very popular in the financial industry, have industry recognition, business people and investors like me and like my business. I am getting more and more popular. My case worth 100’s of million dollars, one million or a few million dollar’ legal fee and expenses is cheap if you could win and clear my name, a penny is too much  for dumpt-trucker, this is a serious business. To test if you are real lawyer or a dumpt-trucker is my case.

I have money and a lot of money in my business accounts frozen or taken by authorities illegally and unseasonably, mistakenly, I need good lawyer to get it for me, can any lawyers get it for my defence in Canada?  I would have unlimited money if you can give me excellent and right legal access. I do not have money because my name, my business and resources and defence and other the accesses have all been destroyed by OSC and the crown on purpose, therefore, I did not a lawyer, any lawyer,  how can I have money and defence? I know you are very rich, as big lawyers you could make real money or a lot of money by protecting and restoring people’s name and business, not just finish one case or another like you and other lawyers did.

Every lawyer in Canada would be interested in my case only if I have the money and give it to him. Nobody in the law society in Canada is interested to make money, to sell service and product, they do not give people any confidence, the skills. They have no estimation and no promise, not make offer, but only sell their time, what kind of business like this? Our justice system and law society has some serious problems. I need good lawyers to have money, not good money to have good lawyers, money follows performance, not the other way around, It is rock and hard place and difficult to find a real defence lawyer in Canada.

My financial trading is legal business and common practice, not criminal activity, I ‘m not a criminal, I always want to trade to make money for my defence and my investors, asked for OSC cease trading order to be lifted after investigation and had vast majority of investors support and authorization in 2009 even after charged fraud so I could have lot of money to defend myself and I could make money any time if I am allowed to trade legally. Because of the authorities, I do not have access to my money, no access to legal aid, no access to Rowbotham application or charter right application, no access to my vast majority of investors and investors’ resources, no access to trade securities and currencies trading, the authorities treat my business like illegal drugs and drug trafficking business and criminal activities, that is wrong, I ‘m a public figure and everybody is watching me and monitoring me, it is impossible for me to defraud anyone in past, now and in the future.

It is fate that I came to the federal prison, I read a book, called “More than a Carpenter “written by Prof. Josh McDowell in USA, printed and sold over 15 million copies over 100 countries around the World, it is about Jesus Christ and his case. Once I read it and I love it immediately because the case similarity to mine. Similarly, the authorities at that time did not understand Jesus and were very jealous at him for his popularity, wanted to persecute Jesus Christ and found an excuse when Jesus Christ claimed he is the son of God. He was charged with Blasphemy by authorities, convicted and sentenced to death by crucifying.  The most interesting thing and convincing is to prove Jesus’ Identity and his resurrection after death since he is the God and his role and power as God to forgive. The book says why some people called him the lord.  Some people called him liar and others people do not think he can change people’s lives and forgive sins of people, called his lunatic.

People who believe me called me Chinese Warren Buffet and invested money with me, but authorities in North America who do not understand and do not like me said that I billed myself “Chinese Warren buffet “, King of 1% weekly, my theory and practice was crazy and lying. Actually, People does not care what I say, they watch what I do, only believe me after I demonstrated and traded to them real time, live to see if I can make money. The authorities never saw what I did and trade. The Crown think that I was lying to my investors and intending to defraud them so they charged and convicted me wrongfully because they simply do not understand, they ignored investors too and think my investors were crazy and greedy, victims only.

The authorities charged and convicted me fraud over $5000, but the fact is that I gave investors million dollars of my own money, the trial judge had a apprehension of bias and ignore all the evidence support me. My investors believe that I am the “Chinese Warren buffet” so they gave me money to invest and wanted me to trade even after start of their own investigation and  trusted me even after the charge fraud by the authorities, like Jesus, he is the god so he could resurrect after death and can forgive the sins. I   run a sound business and make money so that I am alive and well and have investors support. Who would trust a liar, a fraudster, or an exposed fraudster? No fraud could continue after exposed, right?

唐炜臻

The authorities did not understand and do not want to understand and do not learn, do not want discovery, do not want to listen. They just wanted to “rape” me because I am Chinese Warren Buffett, once one authority raped me, everyone wants to or have to and keep raping like “ animals” , they do not understand the rape victim of the justice system, what even worse than sex offenders is that they do not know they are raping me.

The book is about Jesus Christ and his case and Jesus’ forgiveness of sins of the people, which change my life, my attitude and my forgiveness to the sins of the authorities who destroyed my name, isolated me, restricted me, disabled me, kidnapped me, assaulted me and stripped me from all my financial resources and charter of rights and freedoms,  they  keep exhorted me financially, keep “raping “ me because of the power and their position to rape and made me very mad and drive me crazy, I was worried. It is also very  painful to hear they say  that “it is their job” and  of their opinion “,  “public interest” when I know they are lying to the public and rape them too.

Even though the authorities “raped” me so hard, I am a Chinese, I can not be mad at them and can not be angry at them, nothing I can do to stop them. It is a horrific judicial experience without legal protection and representation, not only to me, not the only victim of the justice system, but also painful to my investors and to my Chinese community, what can I do? Nothing, but learn to forgive just as the Professor did to the man who raped him. The professor Josh McDowell studied Jesus and his forgiveness, He learn to forgive, he forgave a man who raped him for many times when he was a child,  his book has changed a lot of people ‘s lives.

I love the book very much because the case of Jesus, the trial of the Jesus case, the trial of the identity of Jesus’ , I learn how to control my own emotion and always keep positive attitude and have a right spirit to fight and fight to survive, focus  on my own cause and my own business.

After read the book, I understand our authorities much better and why they did all these to me because they do not understand me, my case. I know why they made mistakes the way they make because they all work on the records of foolish and personal opinions, wrong assumptions and false statements of other  authorities, such as the police report and judge’ bias apprehension, opinions and decisions which are often wrong, but everybody use it and have to follow. One authority makes mistake, everybody have to follow, nothing to stop them.

Now I know why our Canadian people have to pay higher tax because what the authorities and bureaucrats do is harmful and costly, especially in the court, justice system of Canada and they all love to air their own opinions, take no pleasure to learn. It is my observation that our authorities in the prosecution and justice system are rapists who drive people crazy and they are worse than criminals.

Most authorities do not understand the cases, but they say they do simply because they are the authorities and know how to make people believe them too. The bible says a fool find no pleasure to know and understand, but are very delighted to air their opinions and make statement and speculations, that is the authorities. There are overwhelming of evidence in my case which make my case useful and extremely valuable.

My case is well documented and could be a classic example and very useful to see how our justice and conviction system works. It could make very good case law for the securities industry and justice system if we are fighting the system together and successfully.

I need help from the public and lawyers like you, but I do not have access to many things, if you could make me to have all the accesses, you are making great business and money and history.  Last, not the least, in the book of the Professor, it says how can the authorities keep a good man down?  

In case you or any of your friends in law society are really interested in my case and need to contact me, you can contact my wife in Toronto, she has lot of court documents and transcripts for your reference, I need you help to get appal bail to work with you, my home contact Info:


My Email: [email protected]

Sincerely yours,

Weizhen Tang