本帖最后由 estoy1 于 2010-5-10 12:08 编辑
Wow. Peace of Heaven. I would like to say Giorgia's voice is really the heavenly voice. You are right, her voice is different from Sarah B's. And I love Giorgia's performing style more, because she is singing with her whole body, whole heart and whole spirit. She appears like a graceful Princess. That's not easy. On the other hand, Sarah B always performs as a fairy lady or a witch-wise woman, revealing a sense of mystery, though. When we compare their voices per se, I would like to say that Giorgia's voice is brighter and richer than Sarah B's.
Thanks very much for all your replies and comments.
Hehe, you are humourous, where did I say Fumant’s voice is very different from S Brightman’s? I have not said it yet. Here, now I do. Thanks for leading me on. :smile:
I agree with you what makes G. Fumanti outstanding is that she sings with her whole heart, body , and soul, and you can hear it , feel it . She conveys a strong sense of purity, nothing that is comparable by Sarah Brightman. :rolleyes: Fumanti and Brightman seem to be similar in music category, but the singing techniques they employ are not exactly the same. Fumanti likes to adopt a more classical approach, while Brightman is a mixture of classical and pop, at times interchanging back and forth, depending on the song. Brightman’s stage shows very often are very commercial , frequently overshadowing her music performance. :rolleyes: There are occasions I cant accept why her voice comes out so weak in classical singing, whereas in pop music she does sound much louder and clearer( I like her singing in the Phantom of the Opera v. much though) . Her fans might not agree with what I said, I would think she sounded much better in pop songs . (If you listen to how she sings in this link, you would know what I mean . [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89IRGoggjWMhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89IRGoggjWMhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89IRGoggjWM[/url]]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89IRGoggjWMhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89IRGoggjWMhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89IRGoggjWM[/url][/url][/url] )
With Giorgia, there is clear fluidity , smoothness, richness and colours even at the high octave. She expresses a good sense of positive energy by her feelings, passion, and her ability to maintain a very sound and crisp vocal volume at high pitch. In her, I see grace, humanity, beauty , and the talent of a high- spirited individual. Although she seems to have a tiny little accent in her English singing(I had difficulty in catching some words), that’s ok, she is a multi-lingual Canadian and an International figure. She will have lots of future ahead.
Talking about the wickedness of S Brightman, have you seen her controversial official youtube video singing Ave Maria ?
Let’s listen to these two videos :
Giorgia Fumanti - A Rose Among Thorns ( Tune of Nella Fantasia )
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gr3DfK5xCMk
Sarah Brightman - Nella Fantasia
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eS6ReUWUZg4
(changed video May 10 2010. The last video is no longer available.) |