|
[i]最初由[gezza]发布[/i]
I happened to come across this case tonight, for the first time. While fully sympathizing with this senior couple who's been through their mishaps, I can help asking the following quetions:
1, If they were here for bereavement, why did they NEED to apply for refugee status? And on what grounds? We've seen plenty of parents coming to mourn their children, but have yet to see one stay to apply for refugee status.
2, As some have pointed out, the whole story does not hold much water, e.g. their son was ''wrongly killed", their social benefit is not enough to cover their daily livelihood that they picked up remains from store, the lady drank toilet water, etc... We all know quite a percentage of Canadians, many younger thus supposely more needy than they, live on social benefits and rarely report such misery. Such incidents can only undermine their credibility.
3, The sister's case is also dubious - she came here on visitor visa, but what status was she on later? Though there's no mentioning, it's not too hard to guess. This reeks that the whole family just wanted to remain in Canada unconditionally.
4, Even if they have been financially depleted to this point and decided to go back to China, they can just tell CIC and they will be put on and plane at public expenses. Where's the need for the donation for the air fare?
I appreciate the good will in raising fund to support them, but I don't see the indignation with Canadian authority and the suspicion of racial abuse, etc.
非常同意.
看完整篇报道, 觉得疑点太多. 给人的感觉是, 两个老人和他们的女儿就是想留在加拿大. 否则, 为什么老人会申请难民? 他们的女儿为什么拿着旅游签证在加拿大非法居留? 现在他们的难民申请被拒,所以想在临走的时候捞一笔, 或者是让华人社区帮助他们继续留在这里.
两个老人一边拿着加拿大政府的福利, 一边把加拿大骂得一钱不值, 这样做是不是很不厚道? 两个老人不是加拿大居民, 却可以从加拿大政府领到每月几百的救济金, 加拿大已经是仁至义尽了. 两个老人还嫌不够, 是不是要政府每个月发几千元给他们? 几百块钱当然不够两个人用, 但问题是加拿大并没有义务去保障两个非法居留者的生活. 老人家目前生活贫困, 但这是他们自己造成的. 如果不是他们当初留在这里不走, 就不会这样. 这也能怪加拿大?
老人丧子之痛虽然令人同情, 但没有任何证据说明他们的儿子是"屈死". 他们打官司失败就说"加拿大欺负人", 这是什么道理? 他们官司失败是因为没有证据. 两个老人根本没有看到他们的儿子和别人打架时的经过, 凭什么说他们的儿子是"屈死"? 如果我在中国打官司输了, 是不是我也可以说"中国欺负人"?
说到"连马桶的水都喝过"的问题, 记者在采访的时候有没有问过老太太为什么会喝马桶的水? 如果是被人强迫喝的, 那他们要求赔100万都合理. 如果是老太太自己喝的. 那是不是因为没有别的水可以喝? 首先我不相信精神病院里不提供饮用水. 就算没有, 通常马桶旁边都应该有洗手池,老太太完全可以喝自来水. 如果是在有水的情况下老太太自己喝了马桶的水, 那确实是精神有点问题. 还有一个可能就是"连马桶的水都喝过"之说是编造的.
两个老人虽然很不幸, 但他们的做法却不可取. 而媒体不负责任的失实报道就更不可取. |
|